Best cast iron Dutch oven: Lodge 4.5-Quart Cornflower Blue Essential Enamel Cast Iron Dutch Oven, $90 at Lodge Cast Iron
“It really is high quality,” Moon explains. “It's just cast iron, [and] you've got the enamel, so you've got a little bit of non-stick surface. Plus, [the enamel] makes it easier to clean, and you don't have to season it as much as you would with an exposed seasoned cast iron pot of any kind.”
Unlike other cookware materials, she notes that cast iron holds heat incredibly well, making it the go-to for even roasts, crispy edges, and decadent braises. “So, even if I'm only making two salmon fillets, or I'm reducing and caramelizing some mushrooms in a sauce, this gives it room to kind of cook off its liquids without getting soggy or steamed and start getting nice and crispy,” she says.
It also does double-duty on the stove and in the oven, even with the lid on. “It's got a metallic handle so you can feel a little more comfortable adding the entire thing into the oven,” Moon says. “So if you have a roasted chicken and you want to start with it covered and then, you know, finish it under the broiler — the cover off — that works well.”
Moon’s own culinary affair with Lodge Dutch ovens goes back to college — safe to say, she’s no longer on her first. “My older sister gave me one of these when I was maybe in college or just out of college, and she gave me the smaller kind of starter one,” says Moon. When she was older, “I upgraded to the 4.5-quart, which is a little bit bigger just to make room for larger dishes. So, I grew up a little bit there, but I love it. It's really just me and my husband, so I don't need the giant one.”
It's also beautiful, said Moon. “This is truly something that I would take maybe out of the oven and place at the center of the table just because it's pretty.”